Metal Roofing Bids & Quotes: How to Pick the Best Price For You

Once you’ve found the best pool of metal roof contractors, it’s time to get bids for your project from each one. Know what to look for in a bid/quote and what could be a red flag.

Finding qualified metal roofing contractors to bid on your roof project is one step of the installation process. The next step is equally as important: Understanding the bids/quotes you receive during the consultation and ultimately choosing the best one for you.

You might be thinking to yourself: “Well, all of the contractors I consulted with are qualified and able to successfully install a metal roof…”

While this might be true, there are specific items to look for in a quote to ensure you’re getting everything required to make a metal roof function correctly and still get a fair price.

At Sheffield Metals, we know how important it is that you only go through the metal roof installation process one time without any hiccups — part of which relies on choosing the best bid or quote.

In this article, we will discuss:

  • What to expect during a roofing consultation.
  • The important items to look for in the quote.
  • Reasons why a quote or bid is too high or too low.
  • Recommendations for choosing the best bid.

Click here to download the Finding a Qualified Metal Roofing Contractor guide!

What to Expect During the Bidding/Quoting Process

The consultation is your opportunity to measure the contractor up, get to know their business, test their capabilities, ask questions, and decide if you’d be comfortable with hiring them. Here’s what you can expect during a metal roof install consultation:

  • A site inspection by the contractor, which will focus on the following:
    • Penetration points
    • Flashing zones
    • Potential problem areas
    • Low spots
    • Differing roof planes
    • Gutters
    • Roof access
    • Surrounding landscape
  • A field measurement to determine the take-off, or the quantity and sizing of materials that the estimator needs to put together a bid or quote.
  • Sitting down with the contractor to give you some ideas to think about and provide options pertaining to:
    • Roof style
    • Metal material choices
    • Colors and finishes
    • Panel profiles or seam type
    • Accessories – Such as underlayment, fasteners, etc.
    • Add-ons – Such as skylights, snow retention systems, etc.
A consultation with a metal roofing contractor regarding the installation of a metal roof
  • Talking through how payment is handled, whether it will be financed, paid in cash or credit, or covered by an insurance provider.
    • You should discuss what percentage of the bill needs to be paid upfront and how the remainder should be paid.
    • Industry professionals recommend that 20% to 30% should be left to pay at the time of completion.
  • Talking through any questions you have for the contractor.
  • Going through the bid/quote the contractor has drawn up based on the field measurement, site inspection, and product choices.
    • Some contractors may give you one quote for the project and while others provide “good, better, and best” options based on different products (with varying quality) used at each level.
  • A roofing contractor can only estimate what they can see, so this is also a good time to talk with your contractor about potential unforeseen problems, how they could be resolved, and what they might cost.
    • Examples of this could be mold that has penetrated the roof deck or a total roof deck replacement to fix damaged or aged decking.

Most roofing contractor consultations last anywhere from one to two hours, but are dependent on the complexity of the roof, how long the sit-down conversation lasts, and how long it takes for the contractor to draw up the quote.

What to Look for in a Roofing Bid or Quote

When you’re going over the bids or quotes provided by your narrowed pool of contractors, knowing exactly what should be included makes a monumental difference. The document should include the entire cost of the metal roof along with a full scope of the work to be completed. This includes:

Roof specs:

  • Pitch/slope
  • Square footage
  • Layers
  • Number of flashings/penetrations

Material costs:

  • Cost of metal + quantity/size
  • Cost of plywood or other roof deck materials + quantity/size
  • Cost of underlayment + quantity/size
  • Cost of fasteners, rivets, or screws + quantity
  • Cost of clips or clamps + quantity
  • Cost of flashings or pipe boots + quantity/size
  • Cost of sealants or butyl tape + quantity
  • Any other material required (drip edge, gutters, etc.)

Labor costs:

  • Tear-off cost per hour + the number of hours to complete tear-off (shingles, metal, etc.)
  • Installation cost per hour + the number of hours to complete installation
    • Includes panel install, accessory install, drip edge install, roof deck installation or repair, and other added materials that require installation time.
    • Always ask if the contractor uses manufacturer details, which are industry-approved installation methods. Keep in mind that some of these details could cost more. That being said, using manufacturer details is the best way to ensure the success of an installation.

Available warranties:

  • Paint, substrate, workmanship, weathertight (commercial projects only), etc.
  • Many warranties are included with purchasing a metal roof, but there could be ones that come at a cost and/or aren’t transferrable under certain conditions. If it is new construction and you are purchasing a home with a metal roof, it is worth contacting the builder to verify that the manufacturer is willing to transfer the warranty in such a case.

Choosing the Best Metal Roof Bid/Quote for You

We wish we could just tell you there will always be a clear best choice among the bids you receive. While that may be true for some property owners, it could be a little more difficult for others. The best thing you can do is to be educated on the reasons the cost listed on the quote may be high or low. This can help you rule out quotes that may not be an appropriate fit.

Why a Metal Roofing Bid Might Be Low

You might be thinking that you’ll just take the lowest quote that you receive. It’s true that it may end up being a perfectly fine choice, especially if the contractor is trustworthy and experienced. However, there’s also the other side where the contractor is actually unqualified or has bad intentions, which is why the price is lower and could lead to system failures and other issues (such as oil canning, leaks, or corrosion).

Let’s go through some acceptable and unacceptable reasons a bid is low.

Acceptable Reasons for a Bid to Be Low

#1: The contracting business is smaller and has fewer overhead costs to compensate for.

#2: The roof isn’t complex (i.e. it has simple planes or few roof penetrations).

#3: The old roof doesn’t need to be torn off.

#4: The contractor uses portable rollforming equipment or buys from a regional manufacturer.

#5: The contracting business is larger and has more buying power and access to lower prices.

#6: The business is newer but still has experienced employees.

#7: The economy is stale, so the contractor is trying to stay busy.

(post) What Is Standing Seam Metal Roofing? Comparisons, Types, & Uses

Unacceptable Reasons for a Bid to Be Low

#1: The proposed materials are low-quality or cheap.

#2: The contractor forgot to include an item in the bid, such as an entire roof plane, penetration points, flashing, accessories, etc.

#3: The contractor is using or employing underqualified or low-wage workers.

#4: A contractor is deliberately undercutting the price of a competitor they don’t like and not focusing on the customer or the project.

#5: The business is new and/or inexperienced in metal roof installation.

#6: The contractor isn’t offering warranties, whether it’s for the workmanship, paint, substrate, or otherwise.

#7: The contractor proposes using different materials on unseen or less visible areas of the roof, such as the back of a home or building.

Why a Metal Roofing Bid Might Be High

While we are discussing bids being too low, one or more bids might come in at a price noticeably higher than the others. High bids are difficult to put into acceptable or unacceptable categories because it’s subjective and up to the consumer to define. That being said, we still think it’s important to talk about these:

#1: Miscalculation, such as a human accounting error, an incorrectly measured roof, or getting quoted for the wrong material that is higher in price.

  • Often times it is easier to walk away thinking the contractor is trying to pull one over on you; however, more often than not, it is worth having a candid conversation about this.

#2: The contractor only quoted you high in materials and attempts to upsell every product.

#3: The contracting company doesn’t think you’re a good fit for them and tries to raise the price so you don’t choose their bid.

  • Believe it or not, there are contracting companies who meet with a prospective customer and come out of the meeting not wanting or able to do the roofing project. This can be because the roof is too complex, the contractor viewed the customer as “high maintenance,” the contractor was asked to bid and cannot do it within the desired time frame, or the contractor didn’t feel the chemistry was right. We’re not saying this is an ethical practice, but it does happen from time to time.

#4: The roof structure is very complex and requires a more extensive installation schedule.

#5: The old roof is difficult to tear off and requires extra labor.

#6: The contractors belong to a union (Union contractors typically cost more when compared to non-union contractors).

  • This is not bad because union contractors are generally very skilled and thoroughly trained. It may be worth asking if the labor was bid using apprentice or journeyman laborers.

What Metal Roofing Quote/Bid Should You Take?

A roof is an all-or-nothing proposition; you can’t just tear off half of it and then not finish the project, which is why it’s critical to choose the right bid from the right contractor the first time.

So which bid should you take?

First and foremost, it has to fit your budget and what you feel comfortable spending on a metal roof. If you try to overextend your budget too much, you could put yourself in a bad financial situation that affects other areas of your life.

Second, ensure the bid/quote contains the correct style for your roofing requirements. It’s imperative to check the manufacturer’s minimum slope requirements before installation. For example, standing seam metal roofing is not “one size fits all”. If you have a low-slope application (3/12 or less is the industry standard), it is important that the contractor plans to use a mechanical system that is double-locked. If you have a steep-slope application (greater than 3/12 is the industry standard), snap-lock systems with a clip would be acceptable.

Third and most importantly, you should choose the bid you feel most comfortable with. If you’ve received bids from experienced contractors who are trustworthy and their quotes/bids contain the attributes described in this article, it’s likely a good choice. Additionally, once you do choose the bid that you feel best about, make sure to keep an open dialogue with your contact at the contracting company throughout the project to ensure the bid price is followed as closely as possible.

an image of a standing seam roof next to a worker installing valley metal

Final Thoughts on Choosing the Best Roofing Quote

Choosing a metal roofing bid or quote can be stressful, but if you educate yourself on how to analyze them, you’re more likely to make the best choice for you.

To recap, always make sure you check:

  • The entire scope of the project is included in the bid/quote.
  • The contractor isn’t overcharging you.
  • The contractor isn’t undercharging you.
  • The quote/bid is within your budget range.
  • The quote/bid has the correct application for your roof.

At Sheffield Metals, we strive to help you choose the best bid for you because we know how important it is for you to protect your investment, especially when it comes to something as important as a roof.

Contact our team of metal roofing specialists today to discuss your questions about bids, picking out a contractor, and more!

New call-to-action